Saturday, November 23, 2024

Tuesday briefing: As Harris clinches the nomination, Trump’s team readies a new attack plan

Must read

Good morning. Last night, Kamala Harris reached the tally of Democratic delegates she needs to be confirmed as her party’s nominee for president. In a strikingly energetic speech to jubilant campaign staff at what has suddenly become her headquarters in Delaware, after Joe Biden called in by phone to support her, she said she planned to “unite our Democratic party, to unite our nation, and to win this election.” She added: “The baton is in our hands”.

As her party coalesced around her at dizzying speed, the Republicans were in the middle of an almighty pivot of their own. Having devoted vast resources to painting Joe Biden as too old and cognitively impaired to do the job, they must now make a plan to deal with a candidate who is almost two decades younger than their own and thoroughly capable of taking him on.

That necessity is a huge headache for the Trump campaign – but it comes with opportunities, too. For today’s newsletter, I asked Hugo Lowell, the Guardian’s senior US political correspondent, to explain what we know about the Trump playbook for Harris – and what they’re still trying to figure out themselves. Here are the headlines.

Five big stories

  1. Violence against women | Two million women are estimated to be victims of violence perpetrated by men each year in an epidemic so serious it amounts to a “national emergency”, police chiefs have warned. The number of recorded offences has grown by 37% in the past five years.

  2. Conservative leadership | The Tories will elect their new leader in November after the party agreed to an extended timetable to replace Rishi Sunak. MPs will whittle a shortlist of four candidates down to two before members have the final say, with Sunak staying in place until his successor is agreed.

  3. Israel-Gaza war | The Israeli military has ordered Palestinians to leave a number of neighbourhoods in the southern city of Khan Younis, including areas that had been designated by the military as part of a humanitarian zone. An estimated 400,000 people sheltering in the city were affected by the order.

  4. Child poverty | Keir Starmer has indicated for the first time that he will consider scrapping the two-child benefit cap, amid a brewing rebellion by Labour MPs. The prime minister endorsed comments by Bridget Phillipson, the education secretary, who said that removing the cap was under review.

  5. Media | Former chancellor Nadhim Zahawi has approached billionaire backers about financing a potential £600m bid for the Telegraph newspapers and Spectator magazine. Zahawi is reportedly in talks with an Abu Dhabi-based investment vehicle, with others in the frame including advertising mogul and Conservative peer Lord Saatchi.

In depth: ‘Their principal enemy has disappeared’

Donald Trump, whose campaign managers described running against Biden as a ‘gift’. Photograph: Brendan Smialowski/AFP/Getty Images

In a fascinating profile of Trump campaign managers Chris LaCivita and Susie Wiles this month, the Atlantic’s Tim Alberta laid out just how deeply their strategy depended on having Biden as their opponent.

The race would be “a contrast of strength versus weakness”, Alberta wrote. “Trump … would be cast as the dauntless and forceful alpha, while Biden would be painted as the pitiable old heel … their campaign has been engineered in every way – from the voters they target to the viral memes they create – to defeat Biden.” Wiles said cheerfully: “Joe Biden is a gift.”

Now that gift has been snatched away. “Their campaign was constructed from the ground up in November 2022 to beat one man,” Hugo Lowell said. “And now their principal enemy has disappeared, and they’re trying to pivot very quickly. It’s difficult to articulate just how big a problem this is for them.”

On the other hand, he added: “They’re good at this.”


How the Trump campaign has recalibrated

As it became clear what a disaster last month’s debate had been for Biden, Trump became noticeably less vocal about his opponent’s weaknesses. Meanwhile, the campaign held back advertising that was critical of Biden, the New York Times reported (£).

The campaign started preparing opposition research dossiers on Harris in recent weeks, Hugo reported. So did Maga Inc, a Trump-supporting political action committee run independently of the campaign. A wave of new attack ads against Harris are ready to be released in key states, including an immediate $5m (£3.9m) ad buy from Maga Inc.

They have also tested messages about Harris with voters to see what works – but any such effort is inevitably less robust than the Biden playbook was. “They spent months poll testing, strategising, and then repeating the same lines again and again,” Hugo said. “That messaging – the court cases as a partisan witch-hunt, crooked Joe Biden – is engrained. Everyone knows it.

“They don’t have those pithy messages in the electorate’s mind about Harris. When I talk to them privately, it’s all very broad brush – they will eventually settle on a few, but they haven’t figured it out yet.”


How they will use Biden’s record to attack Harris

The most obvious way to take on Harris is to link her to Biden, in the hope that his unpopularity will rub off on her and she will be unable to plausibly cast herself as a change candidate.

David Urban, a Republican strategist who was an adviser on Trump’s last two campaigns, told the Washington Post that the two were “interchangeable”. “She is complicit in every bad decision he’s made,” he said. That line has been echoed by many other Republicans over the last 36 hours. “They want to hang every perceived policy failure around her neck,” Hugo said. There is likely to be a particular focus on two issues where the Republicans believe voters are disappointed by Biden: immigration and the cost of living.

Biden tasked Harris with tackling irregular immigration at the southern border of the US, asking her to address the root causes of the issue by working to improve economic and security conditions in central America. While that was a bit of a cursed assignment, it allowed Republicans to call her the “border tsar” – inaccurate since her brief was to focus on long-term solutions, but certainly pithy. “That will work just fine,” Hugo said. “But it isn’t nearly as engrained as the messaging about Biden.”

Meanwhile, although many experts say that Biden has presided over an impressive economic revival, Republicans hope that Americans unhappy with inflation and high interest rates will blame Harris as much as her boss.


How they will draw on her own record

Before she was nominated as vice-president by Biden, Harris was senator for California and state attorney general there. Outside her record during the last four years, that should provide some further ammunition for the Trump campaign.

During her 2020 presidential run, Harris came under fire both as being too soft on crime and too reluctant to reform the police. Expect the first angle to feature more prominently in any Trump attack. In 2020, Republicans also used the fact that she been rated by a non-partisan group as having the most liberal voting record in the senate to cast her as extreme.

“I would guess that Harris will have a honeymoon week or two while they go back to the 2020 primary and see what stuck,” Hugo said. “And then they will come back with what they conclude works in a focused way.”

One possible avenue: a programme that allowed first-time drug offenders to get a high school diploma and a job instead of going to prison. “Trump’s rhetoric is about ‘illegal immigrant’ drug mules carrying fentanyl across the border and ‘poisoning’ American cities. That draws together immigration, the border, and crime, and allows you to pin it all to Harris.”


How they will describe her as Biden’s ‘puppet-master’

Another potent line of attack is to argue that Biden’s decision proves that he is incapable of being president – and that Harris of all people should have known it. A Maga Inc ad now running in Arizona, Georgia, Nevada and Pennsylvania says: “Kamala knew Joe couldn’t do the job, so she did it. Look what she got done: a border invasion, runaway inflation, the American dream dead.”

Trump’s own campaign has already published ads that claim she always planned to get rid of Biden, showing her laughing as the Biden logo is replaced with her own. And many Trump surrogates have echoed that argument.

Former Trump campaign manager Kellyanne Conway, for example, said that Harris “leads the very long line of Democrats who lacked the courage, integrity and love of country” to persuade Biden to stand down.

“They want to cast her as the puppet-master – a palace intrigue coup organiser who covered up Biden’s decline so she could assume the presidency herself,” Hugo said. “But that’s a very complicated message. Is it really what you’re going to tell people in the rust belt?”


How racist and sexist attacks could feature

As the first woman of colour to be nominated for president by either party, it would be unsurprising if Harris became the subject of bigoted attacks on her candidacy.

skip past newsletter promotion

Trump himself used charged language about Harris in 2020, calling her “nasty” and “disrespectful”; he also gave oxygen to a baseless “birther” conspiracy, claiming that he had heard “she doesn’t meet the requirements … they’re saying that she doesn’t qualify because she wasn’t born in this country”. On Saturday, he called her “crazy” and “nuts”, pointing to her laugh as evidence. (Republicans are, tellingly, preoccupied with her laugh, and have sought to paint her as “cackling Kamala”. They also frequently pronounce her name wrong.)

The other term you may hear a lot more of, if recent media talking points are anything to go by: the idea that Harris is a “DEI hire”, and would be the “first DEI president”. By invoking DEI – or diversity, equity, and inclusion – programmes, Republicans imply that she has succeeded as a result of special allowances made because of her race and gender.

Will that become an explicit part of the campaign? “I’m sure Trump will end up going after the DEI thing, but even if he says stuff like this at rallies to the base, it may fall away as a key message,” Hugo said. “The point is – the campaign doesn’t know yet. They’re trying to figure all this out on the fly, and that’s not a place they want to be at all.”

What else we’ve been reading

Gulalai Reha, 25, playing the sitar in Braga, Portugal, where many Afghan musicians have fled. Photograph: Gonñalo Fonseca/The Guardian
  • Amid a recruitment crisis, Ukraine’s military has freed thousands of convicts under the condition that they indefinitely fight in the war. Luke Harding spoke with some of them. Nimo

  • “Abandon ship? Where? We’re in the middle of the Pacific Ocean”: Simon Hattenstone has an evocative interview with Douglas Robertson, who was shipwrecked with his family, for the latest instalment of the How we survive series. Hannah J Davies, deputy editor, newsletters

  • When the Taliban returned to power in 2021, music was banned in Afghanistan. Ashifa Kassam’s report highlights the stories of musicians, instructors and staff from Afghanistan’s National Institute of Music (above)who fled and have since settled in Braga, Portugal, where they hope to preserve the artistry of their homeland. Nimo

  • From melon with baked halloumi and basil to gammon with butter beans and radishes, Nigel Slater’s rustled up some salads to share … or to keep for yourself. Hannah

  • The Olympics has never quite lived up its ideals (and some of those ideals were never that great to begin with), writes Louisa Thomas for the New Yorker (£). But these games in Paris might be a little different … Nimo

Sport

Eberechi Eze. Photograph: Hassan Ammar/AP

Football | Manchester City are weighing up an approach for Crystal Palace’s Eberechi Eze (above) amid growing uncertainty over the future of Kevin De Bruyne. De Bruyne has one year on his contract and is wanted by the Saudi Arabian side Al-Ittihad.

Olympics | Thomas Portes, an MP for the radical-left France Unbowed party, has sparked outrage after saying Israeli athletes are not welcome at the Paris Olympic Games, calling for protests against their presence due to the war in Gaza. Portes later told Le Parisien newspaper that French diplomats should put pressure on the International Olympic Committee to ban the Israeli flag and anthem at the games.

Rugby | England’s most-capped player, Ben Youngs, has revealed he had heart surgery after collapsing during an open training session. The Leicester scrum-half says he is “on the mend” and hopes to be fit for the new season in September.

The front pages

Kamala Harris remains the big subject in the UK papers this morning. Page one of the Guardian says “Senior Democrats throw weight behind Harris to take on Trump”. “Coronation for Harris as rivals step aside” – that’s the Daily Telegraph, while the i calls Kamala Harris “The anointed”. The Times’ splash headline is “Donor dollars pour in as Harris promises victory”. “Harris close to sealing nomination as Democratic grandees add support” – US Democrats would probably wonder what the Financial Times means by calling them “grandees”. “Yes she can” predicts the Metro as “Democrats surge behind Kamala”.

Casting about for hope somewhere on the right wing of politics, the Daily Express says “Farage: more Tory MPs will soon defect to Reform”. No Kamala Harris on the front of the Daily Mail either – it leads with “Now Labour opens door to giving asylum to 70,000”. “She’s lost her world” – the Daily Mirror covers a family car crash tragedy.

Today in Focus

Kamala Harris. Photograph: Nathan Howard/Reuters

Can Kamala Harris beat Donald Trump?

Endorsements for Harris to be the new Democratic presidential nominee have come thick and fast. But without Joe Biden can the Democrats win the US election? Mehdi Hasan explains

Cartoon of the day | Ben Jennings

Illustration: Ben Jennings/The Guardian

The Upside

A bit of good news to remind you that the world’s not all bad

Jessica Pita, who is blind, says the ocean sounds like an orchestra. Photograph: Chris Scarffe/The Guardian

Jessica Pita has optic atrophy, a condition caused by a brain tumour that pressed on her optic nerves when she was 11. After the tumour was removed, she lost most of her sight.

Nine years later, she went diving for the first time, in Mozambique. Pita was apprehensive as diving is viewed as a “seeing sport” but once she got into the water she was comforted by the noises of the ocean. “I could hear the whole reef, being alive – and it sounded absolutely amazing, like its own kind of orchestra. A sea orchestra,” Pita says. She fell in love with the sport and has since become the first South African blind scuba diver. It has been an liberating experience that has helped her gain a lot more independence and confidence. “It feels empowering, putting my equipment on by myself and experiencing the thrill of diving into the ocean, not knowing what I’m going to encounter,” Pita says.

Sign up here for a weekly roundup of The Upside, sent to you every Sunday

Bored at work?

And finally, the Guardian’s puzzles are here to keep you entertained throughout the day. Until tomorrow.

Latest article