Image from a drop test recorded by Apple Track.
Did the drop test back up Apple’s claim? We will get to that later. The first drop was a pants pocket length drop on the side of the phones. Even though this wasn’t much of a fall, the bottom of both phones suffered some cosmetic injuries in the form of small dents. The next drop, from chest high on the sides of the phones also resulted in some damage to the bottom of the handsets, especially on the iPhone 16 Pro. Keep in mind that these phones are landing on concrete.
Is Apple’s new second-gen Ceramic Shield really 50% stronger?
So while the iPhone 15 Pro was still running after taking basically the same blows as the iPhone 16 Pro, it was the newer unit that was knocked out of commission. Kohl’s theory, which does make sense, is that the 30% smaller bezels are leaving the display on the iPhone 16 Pro more vulnerable in the corners.
The chest-high back drop led both phones to shatter the rear glass in a corner producing the spider web crack that many of us are familiar with. The next test, the head-high back drop, did some serious damage to the iPhone 15 Pro while the iPhone 16 Pro held up better.
That takes us to the screen-down drops which are the ones that most iPhone users are interested in. From waist high, the iPhone 16 Pro had a large scratch alongside the side of the display. The iPhone 15 Pro had smaller damage in the upper corner but otherwise was okay. Amazingly, the iPhone 15 Pro had no problem with the waist-high screen-down drop while the iPhone 16 Pro saw the cracks on its display lengthen.
The 10th drop of the day was an above-the-head screen-down fall that saw the iPhone 16 Pro suffer a little more damage in the areas where it had previously cracked while the iPhone 15 Pro was still holding on. As Kohl noticed by this point, the corners appear to be the iPhone 16 Pro series’ Achilles heel this year.
So what lesson can iPhone users take from this drop test?
Looking to see how high the iPhone 15 Pro would have to fall to crack the screen, both phones were dropped from a much higher distance estimated to be 12-13 feet. That fall finally made the ceramic shield on the iPhone 15 Pro raise the white flag and surrender. Even though the iPhone 16 Pro display stopped working several drops ago, after that last test the screen on the new model held up better overall perhaps giving credence to Apple’s statement that the new Ceramic Shield is 50% stronger than the previous generation which was used on the iPhone 15 Pro.
Looking to see how strong the Ceramic Shield is, both phones were dropped from an even higher distance. Once again, the iPhone 15 Pro screen shattered leaving sharp edges; while the iPhone 16 Pro display was also cracked, the damage was more confined to a specific area and was still smooth enough to run a finger across it. So even higher Sam went with the phones. And while the iPhone 16 Pro display took it on the chin with the next fall, it literally took it on the chin and the damage was contained there.
Looking at both displays side-by-side, you really can see the difference in the Ceramic Screen protection for both phones. Outside of the early hit that stopped the display from working on the iPhone 16 Pro, the second-generation Ceramic Shield does appear to be stronger than the first-generation.