Karger says the fact he was not recognized is an oddity of historical proportions, especially given the fact the movie was so beloved.
“I think Donald Sutherland’s omission from best actor for ‘Ordinary People’ has to rank as one of the most surprising omissions in an acting category, particularly when you look at how much the Academy membership seemed to appreciate the film,” he says. “I am at a loss as to how that could have happened.”
Based on the 1976 book of the same name by Judith Guest, “Ordinary People” is morose and moving. Even at the time, there was a sense Sutherland nailed the part.
“Mr. Sutherland realizes his best film role in years,” The New York Times’ Vincent Canby wrote in his review of the film.
“The father (Donald Sutherland) is one of those men who wants to do and feel the right things, in his own awkward way,” Roger Ebert wrote in his review. “The change he goes through during the movie is one of the saddest ones: Realizing his wife cannot truly care for others, he questions his own love for her for the first time in their marriage.”
“Ordinary People” is known for so many things, including Hutton’s performance and Moore playing someone so opposite what audiences expected from her. And, today, there’s even the idea that the movie helped develop the birth of the Brat Pack, a notion suggested by Andrew McCarthy in his recent Hulu documentary “Brats,” in which he says it’s one of the earliest films to treat young people “very seriously.” He also cites Hutton as “the godfather of the Brat Pack.” But don’t sleep on Sutherland’s contribution to the movie.
For a generation of movie fans who know him from “The Hunger Games” franchise, “Ordinary People” is a lesson about the ability Sutherland possessed. In the 1970s, he made his mark playing offbeat characters in films like “Animal House,” “Kelly’s Heroes” and “M*A*S*H,” but he tried something new with “Ordinary People.”
“I think it did allow him to show different sides of what he could do and I think really helped further his career, which was already going very well,” Karger says.
Karger explains “Don’t Look Now” and “Klute” also stand out as other roles that could’ve netted Sutherland Oscar nominations, while noting that his lack of nominations place him in rarified air.
“I think he belongs on the list of most accomplished performers never to be nominated for a competitive Oscar, alongside people like Edward G. Robinson or Myrna Loy or people who are still working today, like Richard Gere or Kevin Bacon,” he says.
Sutherland would finally have his moment when he received an honorary Oscar in 2017, a sort of recognition that underscores how talented a performer he was. While honoring him when he got his Oscar, his “Hunger Games” co-star Jennifer Lawrence marveled at the fact he was never nominated when she introduced him.
“For someone so generous and talented, it’s odd to think that Donald Sutherland has never won an Oscar before tonight,” she said before reeling off a list of his movies.
“Donald Sutherland’s work is movie magic at its best,” she added later in her speech.
“I wish I could say thank you to all of the characters that I’ve played, thank them for using their lives to inform my life,” Sutherland said in his acceptance speech, adding the recognition was “extraordinary.”
It was a moment seemingly long overdue.
“There’s a very small list of people who are as accomplished and talented as Donald Sutherland was, who never received a competitive nomination,” Karger says.
“And I think it’s no coincidence that the Academy in 2017 gave him an honorary Oscar because I think the board of directors understood that fact, that he was deserving of at the very least a nomination, if not an actual Academy Award.”