Automatic sensor cleaning isn’t essential? My experience would beg to differ

Dust is the plague of digital photography. Every time you zoom in and out with a physically extending lens and more especially when you change lenses on your camera body, you risk dust and other airborne debris getting where it shouldn’t. With a sense of almost absolute inevitability, that dust will end up on your image sensor. And unlike with analog photography, where it’s carried away every time you take a shot and advance the film, it stays put on your sensor, translating into dark spots in the same places on every successive picture.

Naturally, you can invest in one of the best image sensor cleaning kits on the market and manually clean the sensor, but should you need to? On a spending spree a couple of years ago, I bought a Nikon Z6 II and a Nikon fc at the same time. Like with my previous cameras, I’d assumed they’d both feature an automatic image sensor cleaning routine, that I could select via the menu system and run either at startup or shutdown of the camera, or any other time I felt the need. I soon found out that while the option is present and correct on the Z6 II, it’s sadly lacking on the Z fc. In fact, automatic sensor cleaning isn’t featured on any of Nikon’s DX format Z-system cameras, including the Z30, Z50 and Z fc. What I’d like to know is, why not?

The part of my brain that likes to defend Nikon (I’ve long been a fan) jumped to the conclusion that because none of Nikon’s DX format Z-system cameras thus far feature IBIS (In-Body Image Stabilization) they don’t have the wherewithal to vibrate the sensor and shake off any dust. But hang on a minute. No Nikon DSLR has ever featured IBIS, yet most recent models do have automatic sensor cleaning. That includes my relatively ancient D7100, which is now more than 10 years old.

So what difference does it make? As I mentioned, I bought my Z6 II and Z fc at the same time. Since then, I’ve swapped between lenses on Z6 II nearly as many times as I’ve had hot dinners. And I do like hot dinners. Lens changes on the Z fc have been comparatively few and far between, as I’ve mostly stuck with the Nikon Z 28mm f/2.8 SE kit lens that came with it. Even so, I started noticing dark spots in the images from my Z fc a few weeks ago and, after taking a test shot of a white wall with a narrow aperture, discovered many dark spots across the image. I repeated the testing process with my Z6 II and found overwhelming evidence that the latter’s sensor was still pristine.